Glued To My Crafts

Join thousands of others who have gotten GLUED to our craft tutorials!

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Safety Guidelines
  • Seasonal Crafts
    • New Years
    • Valentine’s Day
    • St. Patrick’s Day
    • Spring
    • Easter
    • Mother’s Day
    • Summer
    • Father’s Day
    • Patriotic
    • Halloween
    • Thanksgiving
    • Fall
    • Winter
    • Christmas
    • Snowmen
    • Story Time
  • Monthly Themes
    • January Craft Ideas
    • February Craft Ideas
    • March Craft Ideas
    • April Craft Ideas
    • May Craft Ideas
    • June Craft Ideas
    • July Craft Ideas
    • August Craft Ideas
    • September Crafts
    • October Crafts
    • November Crafts
    • December Crafts
  • Amazon Storefront
  • Privacy Policy

Popsicle Stick Pilgrim Craft Idea For Kids

When engaging in craft activities, it is important for young children to have adult supervision at ALL times. It is also recommended to use supplies that are suitable for your child's age. Feel free to modify materials or steps to meet your specific requirements. Please refer to our safety guidelines for more information.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. This post may contain affiliate links. Glued To My Crafts is independent and not affiliated with or endorsed by the publishers of the books featured on our website. For more information, please see our disclosure policy.

UPDATE FOR 2026 - To reduce storage costs and download fees, we recently made some changes to our website. The password for all our files this year is GLUEDTOMYCRAFTS2026. No sign-up is required to download our free printables! You can enjoy our printables without creating an account or paying for Box.com. Simply follow the download instructions on our FAQ PAGE.

Are you ready for something different? Then you are in the right place with today’s Popsicle Stick Pilgrim Puppet kid craft idea. It’s super easy to make and each one can be customized to fit the Thanksgiving holiday that will be soon upon us!

Keep scrolling and open up a whole new world of craftiness in your home!

Two popsicle stick puppets designed as pilgrims with paper hats, googly eyes, and felt details are displayed on a red background with white and yellow dots—a perfect pilgrim craft for kids. Text reads, POPSICLE STICK PILGRIM PUPPET.

It’s a NEVER before seen idea that is fresh to Glued To My Crafts today!

You can’t help but LOVE today’s pilgrim themed art project. These Thanksgiving puppets are made from wood popsicle sticks, are super adorable, don’t you think?! Plus I love how you turn craft time into play time within a matter of minutes!

Our Popsicle Stick Pilgrim Puppet idea will allow those creative juices to flow, while you create some one-of-a-kind Thanksgiving pieces. We have made it super easy with this pilgrim themed tutorial and we really hope to inspire you to recreate it, while making some awesome memories with your child, this afternoon!

When you are done piecing together your wood and paper pilgrim friends, you can stick them in a flower pot as decor, add a magnet to the back to display on the fridge and/or play with them like puppets. So many possibilities, I just hope to spark the start of the creativity within you right now!

Now what are you waiting for?! These are popsicle stick pilgrims that are too cute to scare! Find all the details below and create one of your own today!

Happy crafting, my friends! Be sure to share pictures of your “not scary” craft stick pilgrim friends with us! You can find us on Facebook and Instagram for easy tagging! I can’t wait to see your pilgrim puppets in action! #gluedtomycrafts

Two popsicle stick puppets designed as pilgrims with paper hats, googly eyes, and felt details are displayed on a red background with white and yellow dots—a perfect pilgrim craft for kids.

With a few popsicle sticks, some paper, and a little imagination, kids can make this adorable pilgrim craft that’s perfect for Thanksgiving!

Craft Supplies:

  • Jumbo Popsicle Sticks – 5 per craft
  • White Craft Paint
  • Gray Craft Paint
  • Small Paper Plate
  • Paint Brushes
  • School Glue
  • White Cardstock Paper
  • Yellow Cardstock Paper
  • Black Cardstock Paper
  • Brown Cardstock Paper
  • Paper Craft Scissors
  • Black Sharpie Marker
  • Small Wiggle Eyes
  • Embellishments

Directions:

  1. First first things – go ahead and glue THREE popsicle sticks together, to look like a triangle.
  2. Set aside to allow them to dry a bit.
  3. When the popsicle stick shape is dry enough, go ahead and grab it, along with the paint brushes, craft paint and paper plate.
  4. Squirt the paint on the paper plate.
  5. Go ahead and paint two sides of the popsicle stick shape completely white, while the remaining one gray.
  6. Set it aside to allow it to dry completely.
  7. The remaining two popsicle sticks will stay nude.
  8. While your popsicle stick shape is drying, grab all your cardstock sheets and scissors.
  9. Cut out a large triangle out of the white paper, that will fit inside the popsicle stick triangle shape you just made. This will be the body of your pilgrim friend.
  10. Now grab your remaining cardstock paper and cut out a circular head, black hat, a belt and anything else you think your scarecrow needs.
  11. Glue on the wiggle eyes and draw on facial characteristics on the head, with your Sharpie marker.
  12. When the popsicle stick triangle shape is dry enough, glue all the paper pieces you made earlier, in their designated spots. The hat goes on top and the belt in the center.
  13. Now you are ready to turn it into a puppet! To finish off the Popsicle Stick Pilgrim Friends – glue the TWO remaining, unpainted popsicle sticks to the BACK of the decorated triangle shape to make arms and the stick that holds the puppet together. See our picture above for an example.
  14. Add any other embellishments you see fit like glitter, stickers, sequins etc.
  15. When done, set it all aside in an undisturbed area so it can dry completely before you display it proudly!
  16. Don’t forget to take pictures and tag us on your social media sites! #gluedtomycrafts

RELATED —> Turkey Hiding In A Pumpkin

A popsicle stick pilgrim puppet craft featuring a black hat, googly eyes, paper belt, and a smile is displayed on a red background with yellow and white dots. Text reads: “POPSICLE STICK PILGRIM PUPPET.” Perfect for a pilgrim kid craft!.

We deliver the BEST kids craft tutorials on the internet, with a hint of unexpected mixed in!

Don’t believe me? Just check out our super popular Pumpkin Owl, Pilgrim Turkey and Sloth In Pumpkin craft tutorials!

All three are simply perfect for your fall crafting plans and would also pair nicely with today’s Popsicle Stick Pilgrim craft tutorial – hint hint!

stacey-signature-2023

A popsicle stick pilgrim puppet craft featuring a black hat, googly eyes, paper belt, and a smile is displayed on a red background with yellow and white dots. Text reads: “POPSICLE STICK PILGRIM PUPPET.” Perfect for a pilgrim kid craft!.
PRINT

Popsicle Stick Pilgrim Craft Idea For Kids

Craft delightful Popsicle Stick Pilgrim Puppets with ease! A fun, creative activity for kids - perfect for Thanksgiving using simple, everyday materials.

Here’s your checklist of supplies to bring this craft to life:

  • 6 Jumbo Popsicle Sticks
  • Cardstock Paper
  • Craft Paint
  • 2 Small Wiggle Eyes
  • 1 Small Paper Plate
  • Paint Brushes
  • School Glue
  • 1 Scissors
  • Sharpie Markers
  • Thanksgiving Book Recommendations - link to our Amazon shop

Prepare your creative haven by laying down a protective cover before the crafting magic begins!

Directions: 
Prevent your screen from going dark

  • First first things - go ahead and glue THREE popsicle sticks together, to look like a triangle.
  • Set aside to allow them to dry a bit.
  • When the popsicle stick shape is dry enough, go ahead and grab it, along with the paint brushes, craft paint and paper plate.
  • Squirt the paint on the paper plate.
  • Go ahead and paint two sides of the popsicle stick shape completely white, while the remaining one gray.
  • Set it aside to allow it to dry completely.
  • The remaining two popsicle sticks will stay nude.
  • While your popsicle stick shape is drying, grab all your cardstock sheets and scissors.
  • Cut out a large triangle out of the white paper, that will fit inside the popsicle stick triangle shape you just made. This will be the body of your pilgrim friend.
  • Now grab your remaining cardstock paper and cut out a circular head, black hat, a belt and anything else you think your scarecrow needs.
  • Glue on the wiggle eyes and draw on facial characteristics on the head, with your Sharpie marker.
  • When the popsicle stick triangle shape is dry enough, glue all the paper pieces you made earlier, in their designated spots. The hat goes on top and the belt in the center.
  • Now you are ready to turn it into a puppet! To finish off the Popsicle Stick Pilgrim Friends – glue the TWO remaining, unpainted popsicle sticks to the BACK of the decorated triangle shape to make arms and the stick that holds the puppet together. See our picture above for an example.
  • Add any other embellishments you see fit like glitter, stickers, sequins etc.
  • When done, set it all aside in an undisturbed area so it can dry completely before you display it proudly!
    Two popsicle stick puppets designed as pilgrims with paper hats, googly eyes, and felt details are displayed on a red background with white and yellow dots—a perfect pilgrim craft for kids.
MINI-HEARTS-page-separator-logo-gluedtomycrafts

Grab our favorite books via our Amazon affiliate link! In our Amazon storefront you will find books, toys and craft supplies we absolutely love using for our Glued To My Crafts tutorials!

A blue text on a white background, perfect for creating a charming the places you'll go keepsake.
CLICK HERE TO PRINT THE DIRECTIONS FOR THIS CRAFT

If you've enjoyed our content or have any thoughts to share, we'd love to hear from you! Mention @gluedtomycrafts or tag #gluedtomycrafts on Instagram!


OUR PRIVACY POLICY

OUR COPYRIGHT POLICY

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Love our crafts?

Follow us on Google

Click & check the box to see us more in your search results!

LOOKING FOR SOMETHING?

EXPLORE OUR SITE:

© 2012–2026 Glued To My Crafts

© All Rights Reserved. All images, artwork, and visual materials contained herein are the exclusive property of the copyright holder and are protected under applicable copyright laws and international treaties. No individual, entity, or organization is authorized to reproduce, distribute, or use any of these images in any manner without express written consent from the copyright holder. The following actions are strictly prohibited: copying, pasting, saving, screenshotting, downloading, or otherwise distributing any images, in whole or in part, by any means or method. Furthermore, it is strictly forbidden to input, upload, submit, or process any of these images through any artificial intelligence system, generative model, machine learning algorithm, neural network, or similar technology for the purpose of creating derivative, modified, reproduced, or newly generated works of any kind. Any output, image, or material generated by artificial intelligence or comparable technology that is derived from, trained upon, or based in any way on these images is likewise subject to this prohibition. Claiming, presenting, or asserting any such AI-generated output as one's own original work is expressly prohibited and constitutes a violation of the copyright holder's rights. Any unauthorized use, reproduction, or exploitation of these images, whether by human or automated means, constitutes copyright infringement. Infringement may result in legal action, including but not limited to claims for damages, injunctive relief, and recovery of legal costs. All rights not expressly granted herein are reserved.

All activities should be supervised by an adult at all times. Please refer to our safety guidelines for more information.


Please note that all the content of the website, including printables, are for classroom and personal use only. This means that any digital item you download from our site can be used for non-commercial use only. We kindly request that you do not reproduce or sell our creations. We appreciate your understanding and cooperation in respecting our content and intellectual property rights.

Accessibility Adjustments

Powered by OneTap

How long do you want to hide the toolbar?
Hide Toolbar Duration
Select your accessibility profile
Vision Impaired Mode
Enhances website's visuals
Seizure Safe Profile
Clear flashes & reduces color
ADHD Friendly Mode
Focused browsing, distraction-free
Blindness Mode
Reduces distractions, improves focus
Epilepsy Safe Mode
Dims colors and stops blinking
Content Modules
Font Size

Default

Line Height

Default

Color Modules
Orientation Modules