
Some of the sweetest Christmas crafts are also the simplest. This Torn Paper Nativity Craft shows Baby Jesus resting on a soft bed of hay. Little hands tear yellow paper, glue it down, and watch the manger come to life.
It’s a gentle, hands-on way to share the Christmas story with kids. While they tear and glue, you can talk about the night Jesus was born. You can tell them how Mary laid Him in a manger because there was no room at the inn. Kids remember what they make, and this craft gives them something to hold while the story sinks in.
Craft Supplies:
Gather these simple supplies before you begin:
- Brown cardstock: this forms the manger base
- Yellow construction paper: for tearing into hay
- Elmer’s school glue: liquid or a glue stick both work
- Crayons or colored pencils: for coloring Baby Jesus
- Scissors: for cutting out the printable (adults may want to handle this for little ones)
- Free printable Baby Jesus: from box.com – password is GLUEDTOMYCRAFTS2026
Directions:
- Start with the printable. Let kids color Baby Jesus’s face and add any details they like. Crayons or colored pencils work best. They won’t bleed through the paper.
- If you didn’t pre-cut it, cut around the outline of Baby Jesus now. Older kids can do this themselves. Remind them to go slowly around the head and blanket.
- This is the fun part! Give each child a sheet of yellow construction paper and let them tear it into strips and small pieces. Long, skinny strips look most like straw. Small, uneven pieces add texture. There’s no wrong way to tear.
- Spread glue across the brown cardstock. Then have kids press the torn yellow pieces onto it. Encourage them to overlap the pieces so the hay looks full and cozy. Leave a little brown peeking through around the edges. It gives the look of a wooden manger holding the straw.
- Flip Baby Jesus over and add glue to the back. Place Him in the middle of the hay and press down gently. Hold for a few seconds so He stays put. Now Baby Jesus is resting in His manger, just like in the Christmas story.
- Set the craft somewhere flat to dry for about 15–30 minutes. If you used a lot of liquid glue, give it a little longer.
RELATED —> Paper Plate Manger Nativity Craft

Everything you need to start is just a click away. Download the free Baby Jesus printable, grab some yellow paper and glue, and let the tearing begin. It’s an easy, meaningful way to bring the true story of Christmas to your kids, one little piece of hay at a time. Happy crafting, my friends!
