Glued To My Crafts

Join thousands of others who have gotten GLUED to our craft tutorials!

Oatmeal Crème Pie Turkey Treats

When engaging in craft activities, it is important for young children to have adult supervision at ALL times. It is also recommended to use supplies that are suitable for your child's age. Feel free to modify materials or steps to meet your specific requirements. Please refer to our safety guidelines for more information.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. This post may contain affiliate links. For more information, please see our disclosure policy.

UPDATE FOR 2026 - To reduce storage costs and download fees, we recently made some changes to our website. The password for all our files this year is GLUEDTOMYCRAFTS2026. No sign-up is required to download our free printables! You can enjoy our printables without creating an account or paying for Box.com. Simply follow the download instructions on our FAQ PAGE.

Four handprint turkey treats are packaged with colorful paper cutout feathers, googly eyes, beaks, and wattles; caption reads Turkey Treats.

Semi-Homemade Crème Pie Handprint Turkey Treats

Crafting delicious, impressive Thanksgiving party favors and classroom treats does not need to be time-consuming or extra expensive either! It only takes a few minutes and a few inexpensive supplies, to recreate our Oatmeal Crème Pie Thanksgiving Treats – I promise!!

In the big scheme of things, the simple embellishments you will add to each pre-packaged oatmeal cookie treat might look like small details but the lucky receiver will surely be impressed!

SO ready, steady, it’s time to go! Find the FULL {and super easy!} step by step turkey stuffed cookie treat tutorial below!

Happy crafting {and gifting} with your littles, my friends! Don’t forget to share pictures afterwards of your semi-homemade turkey cookie treats, with us on our Facebook page wall. I can’t wait to see what you create!

RELATED —> Burlap Pumpkin Pie Gift Tag

A handprint turkey treat cookie with googly eyes and a beak, wrapped in plastic, sits on a brown background with paper feathers. Text at the bottom reads GluedToMyCraftsBlog.com.

Make Thanksgiving extra special by turning simple pre-packaged Oatmeal Crème Pies into Handprint Turkey Treats with this simple handmade add-on idea!!

Treat Materials:

  • Pre-Packaged Oatmeal Crème Pies
  • Cardstock Paper
  • Pencil or Pen
  • Paper Scissors
  • Loose Craft Glitter
  • Large Glue Dots
  • Red Tulip Puffy Paint
  • Orange Tulip Puffy Paint
  • Eyeball Stickers

Directions:

  1. First things first – the handprints!!! For each turkey treat, you will want to trace/trim out your child’s handprint.
  2. Decorate the cutouts with glitter or other embellishments {or leave plain if you choose too.}
  3. Set aside to let them dry completely.
  4. Once dry, add your handprint to the back of the oatmeal pie with a large glue dot. Make sure it’s really secured in place.
  5. On the other side of the crème pie, use your puffy paint to draw on a face for the turkey.
  6. Go ahead and also add on the eyeball stickers
  7. Set aside your finished Handprint Turkey Treats to let them dry completely {an hour or two} then gift away!!!

RELATED —> Semi-Homemade Halloween Melted Pudding Witches

A hand holds a cookie decorated like a turkey, wrapped in plastic, with a brown paper handprint for tail feathers. The text reads GluedToMyCraftsBlog.com and highlights these festive handprint turkey treats.

Be sure to also check out our Give Extra, Get Extra Gift Tag Printable for another Thanksgiving “treat” themed idea!

stacey-signature-2023

Craft Activity Safety Guidelines:

Always Ensure Adult Supervision - Young children should be supervised at all times when engaging in craft activities. This is essential to keep them safe and ensure materials are used correctly. Use Age-Appropriate Supplies - Choose craft supplies that are suitable for your child’s age. Check labels for recommendations and avoid items with small parts or sharp edges for younger children. Modify as Needed - Feel free to adapt materials or steps to meet your child's abilities and safety needs. For example, substitute scissors with safety scissors if necessary. Keep an Eye on Allergies - Be mindful of potential allergens in craft materials like glue, paint, or certain fabrics. Opt for non-toxic and hypoallergenic options whenever possible. Organize and Secure Supplies - Keep all craft tools and materials organized. Store sharp objects, small parts, and potentially hazardous items out of reach when not in use. Following these guidelines will ensure that crafts remain fun, creative, and, most importantly, safe for everyone involved!